What a redemption actually is
A redemption is Michigan's name for a full and final workers' comp settlement. Under MCL 418.835, the employer and insurer pay a lump sum in exchange for a complete release of all liability under the Workers' Disability Compensation Act for the specified injury or occupational disease. It is not enforceable until a workers' compensation magistrate holds a redemption hearing and issues an order approving the settlement.
The magistrate's job at the redemption hearing is to make sure the settlement is in the injured worker's best interest — but magistrates approve the vast majority of redemptions that are presented. The real evaluation of whether the deal is fair happens before the hearing.
Why insurers push for redemptions
An open workers' comp claim is an ongoing liability on the insurer's books. Every week of wage-loss and every medical bill is a running cost. A redemption converts an unpredictable stream of future payments into a fixed number the insurer can close out. Carriers regularly redeem for less than they would end up paying if the claim continued. That's the whole business case for offering a settlement in the first place.
What goes into a fair redemption value
A fair redemption is not a round number — it's the result of a detailed valuation. The main drivers:
Weekly rate and expected duration
Your weekly wage-loss rate multiplied by the number of weeks of disability you can reasonably expect. Age, education, work history, and medical restrictions all factor in.
Future medical exposure
The cost of future surgeries, physical therapy, injections, prescription medications, imaging, and durable medical equipment. The larger this number, the more dangerous a low-ball settlement is.
Litigation risk
Both sides discount for the risk of losing at trial. Strong medical proof of an ongoing, work-related disability drives the value up. Bad IME reports and gaps in treatment drive it down.
Coordination offsets
Michigan allows insurers to coordinate workers' comp with employer-funded pensions, Social Security old-age benefits (for those 65+), and certain other benefits under MCL 418.354. These offsets reduce the "value" of ongoing weekly benefits and therefore reduce redemption value.
Medicare Set-Aside (MSA)
If you are Medicare-eligible or reasonably expected to become eligible within 30 months, a portion of the settlement generally must be set aside in an MSA account to pay for future injury-related treatment before Medicare will cover any of it. Skipping this step can leave you with denied Medicare claims and personal liability for future medical bills.
Traps to avoid before signing
- Signing a "voluntary redemption" from the adjuster with no lawyer. Adjusters do not represent you and are not required to point out benefits you're leaving on the table.
- Redeeming without a Medicare Set-Aside when Medicare's interests must be protected. Denied future coverage can dwarf the settlement itself.
- Settling before maximum medical improvement. If you still need surgery or your condition is still changing, valuing future medical is guesswork.
- Ignoring third-party or product-liability claims. A redemption can affect subrogation rights and reimbursement obligations — and a related civil claim may still be alive.
- Not planning for taxes and benefits impact. Redemption proceeds are generally not taxable as income, but a lump sum can affect Social Security disability offsets, Medicaid eligibility, and needs-based benefits.
How a redemption hearing actually works
-
1
Settlement package prepared. A redemption agreement, medical records, wage records, and Medicare Set-Aside documentation (if applicable) are assembled and filed with the WDCA.
-
2
Magistrate hearing. You appear before a workers' compensation magistrate, answer questions about the injury, the settlement, and whether you understand you're giving up all future benefits.
-
3
Order approving redemption. If approved, the magistrate signs the order. The insurer then has 30 days to pay the settlement.
Was a redemption offer just put on the table?
Call Jay Trucks & Associates before you sign anything. We'll value your case using your medical records, weekly rate, future treatment needs, and Medicare status — and tell you exactly what a fair redemption should look like. Free consultation, zero obligation.